Handel en Mensenrechten: Een Pleidooi voor Verplichte Mensenrechtenclausules in Vrijhandelsovereenkomsten
INLEIDING
De wereld van internationale handel is de afgelopen decennia sterk geëvolueerd. Sinds de jaren '90 is er een verschuiving zichtbaar van multilaterale handelsovereenkomsten naar bilaterale vrijhandelsovereenkomsten (FTA’s). In het kielzog van deze verandering zien we een opmerkelijke ontwikkeling: steeds meer Staten, zowel individuele landen als groepen landen, integreren mensenrechtenclausules in deze FTA’s. Maar ondanks deze positieve trend is de benadering van verschillende landen met betrekking tot mensenrechten in handelsovereenkomsten sterk gefragmenteerd, wat leidt tot rechtsonzekerheid en inconsistente toepassing.
In mijn masterscriptie, getiteld "De verwijzing naar mensenrechten in FTA’s: een vergelijkende analyse en betoog voor een algemene verplichting", analyseer ik de huidige stand van zaken rond mensenrechtenclausules in FTA’s en bepleit ik de noodzaak van een algemene verplichting binnen het Wereldhandelsorganisatie (WTO)-recht om deze clausules in elke FTA op te nemen.
WAT ZIJN MENSENRECHTENCLAUSULES?
Mensenrechtenclausules in FTA’s zijn bepalingen die staten verplichten om basisrechten zoals vastgelegd in internationale verdragen, zoals de Universele Verklaring van de Rechten van de Mens, te respecteren. Deze clausules beogen dat Staten zich niet alleen houden aan economische afspraken, maar ook actief mensenrechten beschermen binnen hun handelsrelaties.
De Europese Unie (EU) loopt voorop in het opnemen van dergelijke clausules. Sinds de jaren '90 heeft de EU een standaardstructuur ontwikkeld voor mensenrechtenclausules in haar vrijhandelsovereenkomsten. De EU definieert mensenrechten als een essentieel onderdeel van deze overeenkomsten, en schendingen kunnen leiden tot sancties of zelfs de opschorting van de overeenkomst. Andere grootmachten, zoals de Verenigde Staten en China, hebben hun eigen benaderingen ontwikkeld, elk met hun specifieke invulling van wat mensenrechtenclausules moeten inhouden.
DE NOODZAAK VAN EEN ALGEMENE VERPLICHTING
Een belangrijke bevinding in mijn onderzoek is dat er wereldwijd geen coherente aanpak bestaat voor het opnemen van mensenrechtenclausules in FTA’s. Deze fragmentatie zorgt voor rechtsonzekerheid en bemoeilijkt de handhaving van mensenrechten. De verschillen tussen de benaderingen van landen en groepen landen zoals de EU, China en de VS illustreren hoe uiteenlopend de standpunten zijn. Terwijl de EU sterk inzet op afdwingbare clausules, gebruikt China deze clausules vaak als een strategisch middel en blijft terughoudend om ze te implementeren.
Mijn pleidooi is gebaseerd op twee argumenten. Het eerste, meer praktische argument stelt dat de huidige versnipperde benadering van mensenrechtenclausules leidt tot onzekerheden en ongelijkheden in de wereldhandel. Een uniform juridisch kader zou niet alleen de naleving van mensenrechten verbeteren, maar ook meer duidelijkheid en stabiliteit bieden in internationale handelsrelaties.
Het tweede argument is eerder theoretisch van aard. Het WTO-recht, dat in essentie bedoeld is om de internationale handel te reguleren, zou volgens mij verder moeten gaan dan puur economische belangen. Het zou een instrument moeten worden dat mensenrechten bevordert. Door een algemene verplichting voor mensenrechtenclausules in FTA’s op te nemen, zou de WTO haar rol als promotor van wereldwijde samenwerking mensenrechten kunnen versterken.
DE EU, VS EN CHINA: EEN VERGELIJKING
Een deel van mijn onderzoek richt zich op de manier waarop verschillende Staten mensenrechtenclausules benaderen. De Europese Unie is wellicht het meest proactief in het opnemen van mensenrechten in haar FTA’s. Vanaf de jaren ‘90 is de EU begonnen met het systematisch opnemen van clausules die de eerbiediging van mensenrechten en democratische principes verplicht stellen. Deze clausules zijn niet vrijblijvend: ze zijn juridisch afdwingbaar en kunnen leiden tot opschorting van handelsvoordelen bij schendingen.
De Verenigde Staten zijn iets voorzichtiger in hun benadering. Aanvankelijk richtten zij zich voornamelijk op arbeidsrechten, met een focus op oneerlijke handelspraktijken zoals de "race to the bottom". Na 2007, onder druk van binnenlandse politieke ontwikkelingen, werden de clausules echter aanzienlijk strenger en beter afdwingbaar. In plaats van vrijblijvende verplichtingen, zijn de VS nu meer geneigd om harde eisen te stellen met betrekking tot mensenrechten en arbeidsnormen.
China, daarentegen, blijft grotendeels terughoudend. Hoewel het land betrokken is bij vrijhandelsovereenkomsten, blijft het opnemen van mensenrechtenclausules voor China controversieel. Vaak beschouwt China dergelijke clausules als inmenging in binnenlandse aangelegenheden, en het is terughoudend om zich aan harde mensenrechtenverplichtingen te binden. Deze terughoudendheid kan leiden tot spanning, vooral in de relaties met de EU, zoals blijkt uit de moeizame onderhandelingen over de Comprehensive Agreement on Investment (CAI) tussen de EU en China.
EEN KWESTIE VAN PRINCIPES EN PRAKTISCHE UITDAGINGEN
Het invoeren van een algemene verplichting om mensenrechtenclausules op te nemen in alle FTA’s zou echter niet zonder uitdagingen zijn. Mijn onderzoek identificeert verschillende obstakels, waaronder de moeilijkheid om tot een bindende internationale consensus te komen. Veel landen zien handel en mensenrechten nog steeds als gescheiden domeinen. Daarnaast zijn er problemen met de afdwingbaarheid van deze clausules. Zonder een sterk juridisch kader kunnen mensenrechtenclausules soms te veel op papier blijven staan en worden ze zelden toegepast in de praktijk.
Desondanks ben ik van mening dat deze obstakels overwonnen kunnen worden. De voordelen van een uniforme benadering van mensenrechten in handelsovereenkomsten wegen zwaarder dan de nadelen. Een sterk juridisch kader, ondersteund door de WTO, zou niet alleen leiden tot een betere naleving van mensenrechten, maar ook tot eerlijkere handelspraktijken wereldwijd.
CONCLUSIE
De integratie van mensenrechten in internationale vrijhandelsovereenkomsten is een stap in de goede richting, maar er moet nog veel gebeuren.
Mijn onderzoek benadrukt de noodzaak van een algemene verplichting binnen het WTO recht om mensenrechtenclausules op te nemen in alle FTA’s. Dit zou leiden tot meer consistentie, afdwingbaarheid en uiteindelijk een sterkere bescherming van mensenrechten wereldwijd.
In een tijd waarin mondiale handelsrelaties steeds complexer worden, is het essentieel dat mensenrechten niet langer als een optionele toevoeging worden gezien, maar als een fundamenteel onderdeel van elke internationale overeenkomst. Het is aan de wereldgemeenschap om de volgende stap te zetten en mensenrechten te verankeren in de structuren van de mondiale handel. Mensenrechten moeten gedijen in het licht van handel, en niet verdwijnen in haar schaduw.
Bibliografie
I. WETGEVING
2000/483/EG: Partnerschapsovereenkomst tussen de leden van de groep van Staten in Afrika, het Caribisch gebied en de Stille Oceaan, enerzijds, en de Europese Gemeenschap en haar lidstaten, anderzijds, ondertekend te Cotonou op 23 juni 2000 - Protocollen - Slotakte - Verklaringen 2000
COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Individual information sheets on implementation of EU Trade Agreements Accompanying the document REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT, THE COUNCIL, THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COMMITTEE AND THE COMMITTEE OF THE REGIONS on Implementation and Enforcement of EU Trade Agreements 2021
COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION ON THE INCLUSION OF RESPECT FOR DEMOCRATIC PRINCIPALES AND HUMAN RIGHTS IN AGREEMENTS BETWEEN THE COMMUNITY AND THIRD COUNTRIES 1995 [51995DC0216]
Communication from the Commission to the Council and the European Parliament - The European Union’s role in promoting human rights and democratisation in third countries 2001
Communication from the Commission to the Council, the European Parliament, the European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions - Global Europe - Competing in the world - A contribution to the EU’s Growth and Jobs Strategy {SEC(2006) 1228} {SEC(2006) 1229} {SEC(2006) 1230} 2006
DISCUSSIENOTA OVER HET IN GOEDE BANEN LEIDEN VAN DE MONDIALISERING 2017
Economische partnerschapsovereenkomst tussen de Cariforum-staten, enerzijds, en de Europese Gemeenschap en haar lidstaten, anderzijds 2017
European Parliament resolution on the human rights and democracy clause in European Union agreements (2005/2057(INI)) 2006
Grondwet van de Volksrepubliek China 1982
Handelsovereenkomst tussen de Europese Unie en haar lidstaten, enerzijds, en Colombia en Peru, anderzijds 2012
MEDEDELING VAN DE COMMISSIE AAN HET EUROPEES PARLEMENT, DE RAAD, HET EUROPEES ECONOMISCH EN SOCIAAL COMITÉ EN HET COMITÉ VAN DE REGIO’S Handel voor iedereen Naar een meer verantwoord handels- en investeringsbeleid 2015
Overeenkomst waarbij een associatie tot stand wordt gebracht tussen de Europese Unie en haar lidstaten, enerzijds, en Midden-Amerika, anderzijds 2012
REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION TO THE COUNCIL AND THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT on the implementation in 1993 of the Resolution of the Council and of the Member States meeting in the Council on human rights, democracy and development, adopted on 28 November 1991 1994
Verordening (EU) 2023/1115 van het Europees Parlement en de Raad van 31 mei 2023 betreffende het op de markt van de Unie aanbieden en de uitvoer uit de Unie van bepaalde grondstoffen en producten die met ontbossing en bosdegradatie verband houden, en tot intrekking van Verordening (EU) nr. 995/2010 (Voor de EER relevante tekst) 2023 (OJ L)
VERSLAG VAN DE COMMISSIE AAN HET EUROPEES PARLEMENT, DE RAAD, HET EUROPEES ECONOMISCH EN SOCIAAL COMITÉ EN HET COMITÉ VAN DE REGIO’S Verslag over de uitvoering van de strategie voor handelsbeleid Handel voor iedereen Zorgen voor een vooruitstrevend handelsbeleid om de mondialisering in goede banen te leiden 2017
Vierde ACS-EEG-overeenkomst: ondertekend op 15 december 1989 te Lomé (Bureau voor officiële publikaties der Europese Gemeenschappen 1992)
Voorstel voor een VERORDENING VAN HET EUROPEES PARLEMENT EN DE RAAD inzake een verbod op met dwangarbeid vervaardigde producten op de markt van de Unie 2022
WERKDOCUMENT VAN DE DIENSTEN VAN DE COMMISSIE SAMENVATTING VAN HET EFFECTBEOORDELINGSVERSLAG tot het minimaliseren van het aan producten die in de Unie in de handel worden gebracht verbonden risico op ontbossing en bosdegradatie bij voorstel voor een VERORDENING VAN HET EUROPEES EN DE RAAD betreffende het op de markt van de Unie aanbieden en de uitvoer uit de Unie van bepaalde grondstoffen en producten die met ontbossing en bosdegradatie verband houden, en tot intrekking van Verordening (EU) nr. 995/2010 2021
II. RECHTSLEER
A Handbook on the WTO Dispute Settlement System (2nd edn, Cambridge University Press 2017) <https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/handbook-on-the-wto-dispute-settle…; accessed 24 April 2024
Aaronson SA, ‘Seeping in Slowly: How Human Rights Concerns Are Penetrating the WTO’ (29 October 2008) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1292065> accessed 1 May 2024
——, ‘Is the Wedding of Trade and Human Rights a Marriage of Convenience or a Lasting Union?’ (17 March 2010) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=1591567> accessed 5 April 2024
Aaronson SA and Zimmerman JM, Trade Imbalance: The Struggle to Weigh Human Rights Concerns in Trade Policymaking (1. publ., Cambridge University Press 2007)
‘Advancing Human Rights through Trade | Chatham House – International Affairs Think Tank’ (26 May 2021) <https://www.chathamhouse.org/2021/05/advancing-human-rights-through-tra…; accessed 30 April 2024
Ansong A, ‘Unclogging WTO Decision-Making with the Provisions on Amendments in Article X of the WTO Agreement’ (2018) 26 African Journal of International and Comparative Law 227
Aristotle, Ross WD and Brown L, The Nicomachean Ethics (Oxford University Press 2009)
Arredondo R, ‘Declaration of Santiago on Democracy and Public Trust: A New Commitment to Good Governance for the Americas, 10th June 2003 (AG/DEC. 31 (XXXIII- O/03)), OXIO 551’ [2020] Oxford Encyclopedia of International Organizations (OXIO) <https://www.academia.edu/94993724/Declaration_of_Santiago_on_Democracy_…; accessed 9 April 2024
Arts K, ‘Het Vierde Verdrag van Lomé: Over Uien, Rum En EG-Prioriteiten’ (1991) 45 Internationale spectator: tijdschrift voor internationale politiek 546
Bartels L, ‘Social Issues: Labour, Environment and Human Rights’, Bilateral and Regional Trade Agreements (Cambridge University Press 2000)
——, Human Rights Conditionality in the EU’s International Agreements (University Press 2005)
——, ‘Human Rights and Sustainable Development Obligations in EU Free Trade Agreements’ (2013) 40 Legal issues of economic integration 297
Becker AC, Elizabeth and Article RWSCRFWFT, ‘Europeans Plan to Press For Tariffs Against U.S’ The New York times (New York, NY, 2003) C1
Beiter KD, ‘Establishing Conformity Between TRIPS and Human Rights: Hierarchy in International Law, Human Rights Obligations of the WTO and Extraterritorial State Obligations Under the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights’ in Hanns Ullrich and others (eds), TRIPS plus 20: From Trade Rules to Market Principles (Springer 2016) <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-48107-3_14> accessed 11 April 2024
Bossche P van den and Zdouc W, The Law and Policy of the World Trade Organization: Text, Cases and Materials (Cambridge University Press 2017)
Brainard L, ‘Trade Policy in the 1990s’ (Brookings, 30 November 1AD) <https://www.brookings.edu/research/trade-policy-in-the-1990s/> accessed 14 April 2023
Bulterman MK, Human Rights in the Treaty Relations of the European Community: Real Virtues Or Virtual Reality? (Intersentia 2001)
Bustamante GA, ‘Human Rights, Economic Liberalism and Social Affairs in Post-Pinochet Chile *’ (2016) 38 Contexto Internacional 133
Canada GA, ‘Canada’s Approach to Advancing Human Rights’ (GAC, 16 October 2015) <https://www.international.gc.ca/world-monde/issues_development-enjeux_d…; accessed 10 April 2024
Chile LT, ‘What Are the Free Trade Agreements in Chile?’ (Biz Latin Hub, 5 November 2019) <https://www.bizlatinhub.com/what-are-free-trade-agreements-chile/> accessed 14 April 2023
‘China’s Trade with World Surges Ninefold after 20 Years in WTO’ (Nikkei Asia) <https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-s-trade-with-world-surges-ninefol…; accessed 6 April 2024
Chorev N, Remaking U.S. Trade Policy: From Protectionism to Globalization (Cornell University Press 2007)
Cottier T, ‘Trade and Human Rights: A Relationship to Discover’ (2002) 5 Journal of international economic law 111
Cuyckens H, ‘Human Rights Clauses in Agreements between the Community and Third Countries. The Case of the Cotonou Agreement’ (2010) Working Papers Institute for International Law of KU Leuven 80
cycles T text provides general information S assumes no liability for the information given being complete or correct D to varying update and Text SCDM up-to-DDTR in the, ‘Topic: Trade in the U.S.’ (Statista) <https://www.statista.com/topics/1308/trade-in-the-us/> accessed 6 April 2024
Davey WJ, ‘Dispute Settlement in the WTO and RTAs: A Comment’ in Lorand Bartels and Federico Ortino (eds), Regional Trade Agreements and the WTO Legal System (Oxford University Press 2006) <https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199206995.003.0015> accessed 24 April 2024
De Baets A, ‘The Impact of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights on the Study of History’ (2009) 48 History and Theory 20
Destler IM, ‘American Trade Politics in 2007: Building Bipartisan Compromise | PIIE’ (2 March 2016) <https://www.piie.com/publications/policy-briefs/american-trade-politics…; accessed 6 April 2024
Dommen C, ‘Raising Human Rights Concerns in the World Trade Organization Actors, Processes and Possible Strategies’ (2002) 24 Human Rights Quarterly 1
Donnelly J and Whelan DJ, International Human Rights (6th edn, Routledge 2020)
Duchâtel M and Hall J, ‘The Human Rights Clause in China-Europe Negotiations’ [2008] China perspectives 91
Dunoff JL, ‘“Trade and”: Recent Developments in Trade Policy and Scholarship--and Their Surprising Political Implications’ (1997) 17 Northwestern journal of international law & business 759
Easton D, The Political System: An Inquiry into the State of Political Science (2. ed, Knopf 1971)
Ebert CD, ‘Effectiveness of Labor Provisions within Free Trade Agreements between the United States and Latin American Countries Note’ (2018) 27 Minnesota Journal of International Law 245
Ebobrah S and Tanoh A, Compendium of African Sub-Regional Human Rights Documents (PULP 2010)
Ebobrah ST, ‘Legitimacy and Feasibility of Human Rights Realisation through Regional Economic Communities in Africa : The Case of the Economic Community of West African States’ (Thesis, University of Pretoria 2010) <https://repository.up.ac.za/handle/2263/27990> accessed 9 April 2024
Eyvazova S and Mammadova D, ‘WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION LAW OR HUMAN RIGHTS – OBLIGATIONS OR RIGHTS’, Economic and social development : 37th International Scientific Conference on Economic and Social Development - ‘Socio Economic Problems of Sustainable Development’ : book of proceedings : Baku, 14-15 February 2019 (Varazdin, Croatia : Varazdin Development and Entrepreneurship Agency 2019)
Farah P and Cima E (eds), China’s Influence on Non-Trade Concerns in International Economic Law (Routledge 2016)
Fierro E, ‘Human Rights Clauses in Financial (Unilateral) Regulations’, The EU’s Approach to Human Rights Conditionality in Practice (Brill Nijhoff 2002) <http://brill.com/display/book/9789004481558/B9789004481558_s015.xml> accessed 8 January 2024
Franca-Filho MT, Lixinski L and Giupponi BO, ‘Protection of Fundamental Rights in Latin American FTAs and MERCOSUR: An Exploratory Agenda’ (2014) 20 European law journal : review of European law in context 811
‘Free Trade Agreements and Singapore’ (Centre for International Law) <https://cil.nus.edu.sg/publication/free-trade-agreements-and-singapore/…; accessed 14 April 2023
Gammage C, ‘A Critique of the Extraterritorial Obligations of the EU in Relation to Human Rights Clauses and Social Norms in EU Free Trade Agreements’ (2018) 2 Europe and the World: A law review <https://uclpress.scienceopen.com/hosted-document?doi=10.14324/111.444.e…; accessed 16 January 2024
Ghazaryan N, ‘A New Generation of Human Rights Clauses? The Case of Association Agreements in the Eastern Neighbourhood’ (2015) 40 European law review 391
GONZÁLEZ CC, ‘Report on the Communication from the Commission on the Inclusion of Respect for Democratic Principles and Human Rights in Agreements between the Community and Third Countries - Committee on Foreign Affairs, Security and Defence Policy | A4-0212/1996 | European Parliament’ <https://www.europarl.europa.eu/doceo/document/A-4-1996-0212_EN.html> accessed 3 April 2024
Hafner-Burton E, Forced to Be Good: Why Trade Agreements Boost Human Rights (Cornell University Press 2009)
Hafner-Burton EM, ‘Trade and Development Agreements for Human Rights?’ (1 January 2012) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2685844> accessed 14 April 2023
Hart M, ‘Coercion or Cooperation; Social Policy and Future Trade Negotiations Sovereignty in the North American Context and in a Changing World’ (1994) 20 Canada-United States Law Journal 351
Hees F van, Protection V. Protectionism: The Use of Human Rights Arguments in the Debate for and Against the Liberalisation of Trade (Åbo akademi 2004)
——, The Use of Human Rights Arguments in the Debate for and Against the Liberalisation of Trade: Protection Vs. Protectionism (2004)
Heyns C, ‘Review of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights: 21 October 1986 to 1 January 1997’, Human Rights Law in Africa 1997 (Brill Nijhoff 1999) <http://brill.com/edcollchap/book/9789004639638/B9789004639638_s006.xml&…; accessed 9 April 2024
Höffe O (ed), John Rawls: A Theory of Justice (Brill 2013)
Hong K, ‘The Impacts of Lisbon Treaty on EU Trade Policy and EU-China Trade Relation’ (Atlantis Press 2017) <https://www.atlantis-press.com/proceedings/iccessh-17/25878700> accessed 27 February 2024
‘Human Rights and Diplomacy: The Koreas, U.S., and China’ (Brookings) <https://www.brookings.edu/articles/human-rights-and-diplomacy-the-korea…; accessed 10 April 2024
‘International Human Rights Law’ (OHCHR) <https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-and-mechanisms/international-human…; accessed 11 April 2024
Internationale Arbeitsorganisation, A Fair Globalization: Creating Opportunities for All (2004)
Ionel Z, ‘Human Rights in EU Trade Agreements’
Jeffrey A, ‘Canada-China Free Trade Agreement Negotiations and Human Rights: A Canadian Perspective’ [2016] Canadian Yearbook of Human Rights 249
Jensen SLB (ed), ‘“Power Carries Its Own Conviction”: The Early Rise and Fall of Humanrights, 1945–1960’, The Making of International Human Rights: The 1960s, Decolonization, and the Reconstruction of Global Values (Cambridge University Press 2016) <https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/making-of-international-human-righ…; accessed 23 April 2024
Johnson ME, ‘CAFTA and International Human Rights in El Salvador: Is the United States Acquiescing to Widespread Workers’ Human Rights Violations? Symposium’ (2005) 4 Northwestern University Journal of International Human Rights 162
Joseph S, Blame It on the WTO? A Human Rights Critique (Oxford University Press 2011)
Juan Carlos Lara and Claudio Ruiz, ‘Free Trade Regional Agreements and Human Rights: the case of TPP and its impact in Chile’ [2016] Anuario de Derechos Humanos 237
Kalaintzis E, ‘Human Rights Clauses in EU Trade and Trade Related Agreements: A Step towards Propelling EU Policies to World Recognition or a Panacea for Winning over the Public Opinion?: Reimagining Political Conditionality by Underpinning Enforceability’ (KU Leuven Faculteit Rechtsgeleerdheid 2017)
Kang N, ‘Normative or Market Power Europe? Elevating Global Labour Standards Through Trade in EU-ROK Relations (2011-2020)’ (2020) 22 The Journal of Applied Business and Economics 63
Karp D, ‘What Is the Responsibility to Respect Human Rights? Reconsidering the “respect, Protect, and Fulfill” Framework’ <https://sussex.figshare.com/articles/journal_contribution/What_is_the_r…; accessed 11 April 2024
Kaufmann C and Meyer L, ‘Trade and Human Rights’ (2007) 1 Human Rights & International Legal Discourse 61
Klein M, ‘The Human Rights Violations of the Pinochet Regime and Their Legacy’ (2003) 74 European Review of Latin American and Caribbean Studies / Revista Europea de Estudios Latinoamericanos y del Caribe 107
Koblanck M, ‘What’s in a Human Rights Clause? : Its Development, Its Application, and an Insight into the Construct of a European Identity’
Koch IE, ‘Dichotomies, Trichotomies or Waves of Duties?’ (2005) 5 Human Rights Law Review 81
Kruger P and Karim SA, ‘Responsiveness of the African Continental Free Trade Agreement to Diet-Related Non-Communicable Diseases: A Human Rights Analysis’ (2022) 22 African Human Rights Law Journal 24
Lavigne M, ‘Conditions for Accession to the EU’ (1998) 40 Comparative Economic Studies 38
Lewis MK, ‘Human Rights Provisions in Free Trade Agreements: Do the Ends Justify the Means?’ (2014) 12 Loyola University Chicago international law review 1
Liao J-J, ‘Strengthening Global Governance for Human Rights through New-Era FTAs: Beyond Trade-Related Aspects?’ (2020) 15 Asian Journal of WTO and International Health Law and Policy 653
Lo C, ‘To Lead or Not to Lead - Reverting President Trump’s Retreat from the United States’ Traditional Leading Role in Promoting Human Rights through Trade Special Issue: Trump’s Trade Policy: Broader Assessment of Trump’s Trade Policy’ (2017) 12 Asian Journal of WTO and International Health Law and Policy 227
Maass M, ‘The European Union, Vietnam, and Human Rights as Law: The Case of the 1995 EU–Vietnam Framework Agreement and Its Human Rights Clause.’ (2012) 10 Asia Europe journal 215
Makarenko A and Chernikova L, ‘“New Generation” EU Free Trade Agreements: A Combination of Traditional and Innovative Mechanisms’ in Julia Kovalchuk (ed), Post-Industrial Society: The Choice Between Innovation and Tradition (Springer International Publishing 2020) <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-59739-9_10> accessed 3 April 2024
Malbon J, ‘The Australia-United States Free Trade Agreement: Trade Trumps Indigenous Interests’ (2004) 111 Media International Australia 34
Mastel G, ‘The Rise of the Free Trade Agreement’ (2004) 47 Challenge 41
McBeth A, International Economic Actors and Human Rights (Routledge 2010)
McFadyen J, ‘NAFTA Supplemental Agreements: Four Year Review | PIIE’ (2 March 2016) <https://www.piie.com/publications/working-papers/nafta-supplemental-agr…; accessed 11 April 2024
Mckenzie L and Meissner KL, ‘Human Rights Conditionality in European Union Trade Negotiations: The Case of the EU–Singapore FTA’ (2017) 55 JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies 832
Men J, ‘Between Human Rights and Sovereignty - An Examination of EU-China Political Relations’ (2011) 17 European Law Journal 534
Mendil MB, ‘La question des droits de l’Homme dans la mise en œuvre de l’accord d’association entre la Tunisie et l’Union Européenne’ (phdthesis, Université de Bretagne Sud 2021) <https://theses.hal.science/tel-03921707> accessed 3 March 2024
Menéndez AJ, ‘Exporting Rights: The Charter of Fundamental Rights, Membership and Foreign Policy of the European Union’ (ARENA 2002) ARENA Working Paper 18 <https://econpapers.repec.org/paper/erparenax/p0081.htm> accessed 3 April 2024
Micara A, ‘Human Rights Protection in New Generation’s Free Trade Agreements of the European Union’ (2019) 23 The international journal of human rights 1447
Musungu SF, ‘Economic Integration and Human Rights in Africa: A Comment on Conceptual Linkages’ (2003) 3 African Human Rights Law Journal 88
Nampewo Z, Mike JH and Wolff J, ‘Respecting, Protecting and Fulfilling the Human Right to Health’ (2022) 21 International Journal for Equity in Health 36
Nkowani Z, ‘International Trade and Labour: A Quest for Moral Legitimacy’ (2009) 8 Journal of International Trade Law and Policy 4
Olson M, Power and Prosperity: Outgrowing Communist and Capitalist Dictatorships (Nachdr, Basic Books 2001)
Ono N, ‘Japan’s Approach to FTAs and IP’ in Christoph Antons and Reto M Hilty (eds), Intellectual Property and Free Trade Agreements in the Asia-Pacific Region (Springer 2015) <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-30888-8_8> accessed 28 March 2024
Padilha S, ‘Trade and Human Rights: Towards Coherence’ (Sur - International Journal on Human Rights, 12 August 2017) <https://sur.conectas.org/en/trade-human-rights-towards-coherence/> accessed 30 April 2024
Paulus A, ‘Reciprocity Revisited’ in Ulrich Fastenrath and others (eds), From Bilateralism to Community Interest: Essays in Honour of Bruno Simma (Oxford University Press 2011) <https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199588817.003.0010> accessed 13 January 2024
Pauwelyn J, Conflict of Norms in Public International Law: How WTO Law Relates to Other Rules of International Law (University Press 2003)
Petersmann E-U, ‘The WTO Constitution and Human Rights’ (2000) 3 Journal of International Economic Law 19
——, ‘Time for a United Nations “Global Compact” for Integrating Human Rights into the Law of Worldwide Organizations: Lessons from European Integration’ (2002) 13 European Journal of International Law 621
——, ‘Human Rights and International Trade Law: Defining and Connecting the Two Fields’ in Thomas Cottier, Joost Pauwelyn and Elisabeth Bürgi (eds), Human Rights and International Trade (Oxford University Press 2005) <https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199285822.003.0002> accessed 26 March 2024
——, ‘The WTO and Regional Trade Agreements as Competing Fora for Constitutional Reforms: Trade and Human Rights’ in Lorand Bartels and Federico Ortino (eds), Regional Trade Agreements and the WTO Legal System (Oxford University Press 2006) <https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199206995.003.0013> accessed 1 May 2024
——, Constitutional Functions and Constitutional Problems of International Economic Law (Routledge 2020) <https://cadmus.eui.eu/handle/1814/69701> accessed 30 April 2024
Pitts JWI, ‘Corporate Social Responsibility: Current Status and Future Evolution Current Issues in Public Policy’ (2008) 6 Rutgers Journal of Law and Public Policy 334
Pleyers G, ‘The Global Justice Movement’
Powell SJ and Perez PC, ‘Global Laws, Local Lives: Impact of the New Regionalism on Human Rights Compliance’ (2011) 17 Buffalo Human Rights Law Review 117
Ramirez LM, ‘Legal Instruments That Safeguard Democracy in the Americas.’ (vLex) <https://law-journals-books.vlex.com/vid/legal-instruments-that-safeguar…; accessed 30 April 2024
Rangel CB, ‘Moving Forward: A New, Bipartisan Trade Policy That Reflects American Values Policy Essay’ (2008) 45 Harvard Journal on Legislation 377
Reich R, ‘Biden Is Turning Away from Free Trade – and That’s a Great Thing’ The Guardian (29 August 2023) <https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/aug/29/biden-is-turning-…; accessed 29 March 2024
Report: The Continental Free Trade Area (CFTA) in a Human Rights Perspective (2017) <https://repository.uneca.org/handle/10855/24089> accessed 30 April 2024
Riedel E and Will M, ‘Human Rights Clauses in External Agreements of the EC’ (1999)
Rona G and Aarons L, ‘State Responsibility to Respect, Protect and Fulfill Human Rights Obligations in Cyberspace’ (26 October 2016) <https://papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2859615> accessed 11 April 2024
Rudra N, ‘Globalization and the Race to the Bottom in Developing Countries: Who Really Gets Hurt?’ (Cambridge Core, September 2008) <http://www.cambridge.org/core/books/globalization-and-the-race-to-the-b…; accessed 26 May 2023
Sanchez L, ‘When It Comes to Free Trade Policy, Human Rights Should Be a Game Changer Policy Essay’ (2015) 52 Harvard Journal on Legislation 343
Schmidt AR, ‘A New Trade Policy for America: Do Labor and Environmental Provisions in Trade Agreements Serve Social Interests or Special Interests Note’ (2009) 19 Indiana International & Comparative Law Review 167
Sen A, Resources, Values and Development (3rd print., Harvard university press 1998)
——, The Standard of Living (University press 1987)
Shestack JJ, ‘The Philosophic Foundations of Human Rights’ (1998) 20 Human Rights Quarterly 201
Simma B, ‘Reciprocity’ Max Planck Encyclopedias of International Law [MPIL]
Skogly S, The Human Rights Obligations of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (Cavendish 2001)
Sohn LB, ‘The Human Rights Law of the Charter’ (1977) 12 Texas International Law Journal 129
——, ‘The New International Law: Protection of the Rights of Individuals Rather Than States’ (1982) 32 American University Law Review 1
Swanson A, ‘Biden’s Reluctant Approach to Free Trade Draws Backlash’ The Economic Times (4 April 2023) <https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/small-biz/trade/exports/insights/b…; accessed 29 March 2024
Sykes AO, ‘The (Limited) Role of Regulatory Harmonization in International Goods and Services Markets’ (1999) 2 Journal of International Economic Law 49
Taylor MR, ‘Inside the EU–China Human Rights Dialogue: Assessing the Practical Delivery of the EU’s Normative Power in a Hostile Environment’ (2022) 44 Journal of European Integration 365
Telo M, ‘Controversial Developments of EU-China Relations: Main Drivers and Geopolitical Implications of the Comprehensive Agreement on Investments’ (2021) 59 Journal of Common Market Studies 162
Tevini, ‘Article XXIV. Territorial Application—Frontier Traffic—Customs Unions And Free-Trade Areas’ in Rüdiger Wolfrum, Peter-Tobias Stoll and Holger Hestermeyer (eds), WTO - Trade in Goods (Brill | Nijhoff 2009) <https://brill.com/view/book/edcoll/9789004180642/Bej.9789004145665.i-12…; accessed 18 April 2023
‘The Charter of the United Nations: A Commentary, Volume II’, , The Charter of the United Nations (Oxford University Press) <http://opil.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/law/9780199639779.001.0001/law-9…; accessed 11 April 2024
‘The Maastricht Principles – ETO Consortium’ <https://www.etoconsortium.org/en/the-maastricht-principles/> accessed 11 April 2024
Tomasevski K and Alston P, ‘Part IV: Implementing the Right to Food’, The Right to Food, vol 4 (BRILL 1987)
Torlai LM, ‘Harmony and Conflict in EU-China Human Rights Relations: The Case of Xinjiang - An Empirical Analysis in Light of Qin Yaqing’s Relational Theory and the Chinese Conception of Human Rights’ (KU Leuven Faculteit Sociale Wetenschappen 2022)
‘United Nations Treaty Collection’ <https://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=TREATY&mtdsg_no=IV-4…; accessed 23 April 2024
‘——’ <https://treaties.un.org/Pages/ViewDetails.aspx?src=TREATY&mtdsg_no=IV-3…; accessed 23 April 2024
Van der Loo G, ‘Lost in Translation? The Comprehensive Agreement on Investment and EU–China Trade Relations.’
Vazquez CM, ‘Trade Sanctions and Human Rights - Past, Present, and Future’ (2003) 6 Journal of International Economic Law 797
Velluti S and Martines F, The Role of the EU in the Promotion of Human Rights and International Labour Standards in Its External Trade Relations (1st ed. 2020., Springer 2020)
Velut JB and others, ‘Comparative Analysis of Trade and Sustainable Development Provisions in Free Trade Agreements’
von der Pfordten D, ‘Five Elements of Normative Ethics - A General Theory of Normative Individualism’ (2012) 15 Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 449
Wehner L, ‘Chile’s Rush to Free Trade Agreements’ (2011) 31 Revista de ciencia política 207
Whelan A (ed), ‘What Is Reciprocity?’, Reciprocity in Public International Law (Cambridge University Press 2023) <https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/reciprocity-in-public-internationa…; accessed 13 January 2024
World Trade Organization (ed), Trade in a Globalizing World (WTO Publ 2008)
Xiangfei Q, ‘Can the Human Rights Clause of the Chinese Constitution Be Interpreted from the International Human Rights Law Perspective?’, Human Rights and Good Governance (Brill Nijhoff 2016) <http://brill.com/display/book/edcoll/9789004308770/B9789004308770-s014…; accessed 14 January 2024
Yigzaw DA, ‘Hierarchy of Norms: The Case for the Primacy of Human Rights over WTO Law’ (2015) 38 Suffolk Transnational Law Review 33
Zhang H, ‘The Problem of the Clause on Human Rights and the Sino-European Agreement on Cooperation’ (2008) 8 Xiandai Guoji Guanxi 40
郭春镇, ‘法律中“人”的形象变迁与“人权条款”之功能’ (Guo Chunzhen, 'The Evolution of the Image of "Person" in Law and the Function of "Human Rights Clauses") [2010] Xueshu yuekan 21
III. ANDERE BRONNEN
‘Afrikaans Handvest en Hof voor Mensenrechten’ (Amnesty International) <https://www.amnesty.nl/encyclopedie/afrikaans-handvest-en-hof-voor-de-m…; accessed 9 April 2024
‘Associatieovereenkomsten’ (ECER) <https://ecer.minbuza.nl/ecer/dossiers/associatieovereenkomsten/associat…; accessed 3 April 2024
‘CPTPP Text and Associated Documents | Australian Government Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade’ <https://www.dfat.gov.au/trade/agreements/in-force/cptpp/official-docume…, https://www.dfat.gov.au/trade/agreements/in-force/cptpp/official-docume…; accessed 29 April 2024
‘Deal on EU Ban on Products Made with Forced Labour | News | European Parliament’ (5 March 2024) <https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20240301IPR18592/deal…; accessed 4 April 2024
‘EU Position in World Trade - European Commission’ (5 April 2024) <https://policy.trade.ec.europa.eu/eu-trade-relationships-country-and-re…; accessed 6 April 2024
‘EU Trade Relations with Israel’ <https://policy.trade.ec.europa.eu/eu-trade-relationships-country-and-re…; accessed 1 May 2024
European Parliament. Directorate General for External Policies of the Union., The European Parliament’s Role in Relation to Human Rights in Trade and Investment Agreements. (Publications Office 2014)
‘Global governance’, , Wikipedia (2024) <https://nl.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Global_governance&oldid=6723…; accessed 24 April 2024
Goode W (ed), ‘H’, Dictionary of Trade Policy Terms (6th edn, Cambridge University Press 2020) <https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/dictionary-of-trade-policy-terms/h…; accessed 9 January 2024
‘Human Rights and Democracy’ (United States Department of State) <https://www.state.gov/policy-issues/human-rights-and-democracy/> accessed 6 April 2024
‘Human Rights and Democracy at the Core of EU External Action | EEAS’ <https://www.eeas.europa.eu/eeas/human-rights-and-democracy-core-eu-exte…; accessed 10 April 2024
‘Human Rights, Democracy and Development Cooperation Policy. Commission Communication to the Council and Parliament. SEC (91) 61 Final, 25 March 1991’ (1991) <https://aei.pitt.edu/2937/> accessed 3 April 2024
‘Human Rights Groups Ask EU to Suspend Trade Agreement with Israel over Violations in Gaza’ <https://www.aa.com.tr/en/europe/human-rights-groups-ask-eu-to-suspend-t…; accessed 1 May 2024
‘Key Elements of the EU-China Comprehensive Agreement’ (European Commission - European Commission) https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_20_2542
‘Menselijke waardigheid, respect en mensenrechten - Amnesty’ (Amnesty International) <https://www.amnesty.nl/encyclopedie/menselijke-waardigheid-en-mensenrec…; accessed 1 May 2024
‘Mexico’s Free Trade Agreements’ <https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/R40784.html> accessed 14 April 2023
Nations U, ‘Human Development Report 2000’ (United Nations 2000) <https://hdr.undp.org/content/human-development-report-2000> accessed 23 April 2024
‘PACE Website’ <https://assembly.coe.int/nw/xml/XRef/Xref-XML2HTML-en.asp?fileid=23489&…; accessed 28 March 2024
Parliament E, ‘EU-China Comprehensive Agreement on Investment (EU-China CAI) | Legislative Train Schedule’ (European Parliament) <https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/theme-a-stronger-europ…; accessed 2 April 2024
‘Protectionisme - EU Monitor’ <https://www.eumonitor.eu/9353000/1/j9vvik7m1c3gyxp/vh7dotydypyv> accessed 11 April 2024
‘Relatie EU en China is verslechterd na veiligheidstop München’ (bnr.nl) <https://www.bnr.nl/nieuws/internationaal/10541079/relatie-eu-en-china-i…; accessed 2 April 2024
Rights UHC for H, ‘Liberalization of Trade in Services and Human Rights :: Report of the High Commissioner’ <https://digitallibrary.un.org/record/468759> accessed 23 April 2024
‘Statement by the Mission of China to the EU on Human Rights Day’ <http://eu.china-mission.gov.cn/eng/gdxw/201912/t20191210_8198089.htm> accessed 3 April 2024
‘Suspend the EU-Israel Association Agreement’ (International Federation for Human Rights) <https://www.fidh.org/en/international-advocacy/european-union/suspend-t…; accessed 1 May 2024
‘Verordening Inzake Ontbossingsvrije Producten - Europese Commissie’ <https://environment.ec.europa.eu/topics/forests/deforestation/regulatio…; accessed 4 April 2024
‘VN-verdragen - 1966 - BuPo - EcSoCu’ (Amnesty International) <https://www.amnesty.nl/encyclopedie/vn-verdragen-1966-vn-verdrag-bupo-v…; accessed 23 April 2024
‘WTO | News - Speech - DG Pascal Lamy - Lamy Calls for Mindset Change to Align Trade and Human Rights’ <https://www.wto.org/english/news_e/sppl_e/sppl146_e.htm> accessed 30 April 2024
‘WTO | Publications’ <https://www.wto.org/english/res_e/publications_e/dictionary_trade_polic…; accessed 1 April 2024
‘WTO | Publications - The Wedding of Trade and Human Rights: Marriage of Convenience or Permanent Match?’ <https://www.wto.org/english/res_e/publications_e/wtr11_forum_e/wtr11_15…; accessed 20 April 2023
‘WTO | The WTO in Brief’ <https://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e/whatis_e/inbrief_e/inbr_e.htm> accessed 11 April 2024
‘WTO | Understanding the WTO - Whose WTO Is It Anyway?’ <https://www.wto.org/english/thewto_e/whatis_e/tif_e/org1_e.htm> accessed 1 May 2024
